By Scott O’Neil
My first interaction with one of my RV dwelling neighbors was when researching Palo Alto’s proposed housing sites on East Meadow Circle in 2022. As I was taking pictures of the smattering of RVs lining the curb, I was approached by a man outside what I learned was his home.
We had a lovely conversation. He’s a custodian working at a business on the Circle. His employer is leaving the area, but he’s nearing retirement age. His RV lets him build his pension until the inevitable layoff, when he will retire to a houseboat on the Delta.
I started to think of these RVs as a “curbside workforce housing program.” It’s not ideal, but I wondered: is this actually worse than the traffic and climate impacts of super-commuting from Los Banos?
Since then, I’ve had several more such conversations. In my experience, RV dwellers are more likely to be young people living independently than my other neighbors. More are people of color. More speak Spanish exclusively. Some are families with young children, as evidenced by scooters or toys. They’re generally employed.
Before parking enforcement started this year, they were also a cohesive community. People knew each other and felt comfortable asking each other for help.
You would never know they were homeless if you passed on the street, yet technically that is how they are classified. The research tells us homelessness is a housing problem. While there’s no correlation nationwide between homelessness rates and oft-cited factors including mental illness, addiction, and weather, there is a dramatic correlation with housing scarcity metrics such as rent levels and vacancy rates.
Counterintuitively, areas with high poverty rates actually have lower homelessness rates! This is because prosperity is what makes it possible to underbuild housing, and drive people onto the curb. If your city is in decline, on the other hand, it does not matter if zoning constrains development. The outmigration and falling rents might make it easier for low-income people to stay housed, and for homeless prevention and rehabilitation services to succeed.
Palo Alto is a prosperous city. Housing production has been stagnant for decades, heightening the housing scarcity that drives homelessness. Given this perfect storm, we’re frankly lucky to have RVs and not tents.
The only long-term answers are to embrace regional decline or more housing. No one wants the myriad problems of decline, but abundance is promising. Research shows that new housing creates downward pressures on rents directly through competition effects. Also, as people move in –and leave vacancies behind– it results in “chains” of housing opportunities which even reach older “naturally affordable” housing stock. People mostly move “up,” so the vacancies they leave tend to be cheaper –even for oft-maligned market-rate “luxury” housing.
Palo Alto, to its credit, has demonstrated intent to spur housing with new policies. These include two Housing Incentive Programs, the Housing Element rezoning, and Planned Home Zoning.
None has produced projects on the scale of the problem. This led some to argue building costs are the issue –not zoning. However, state laws like Builder’s Remedy and SB 79 disproved that theory by spurring spikes in applications purely by relaxing local regulations we otherwise control.
Unfortunately, the SB 79 and Builder’s Remedy windows have closed for now, and no such projects have yet been completed. Even the first stages of relief are far off, and we must decide what to do now.
Finding a better location for RVs is a popular idea. One proposal is to use land around the Baylands as a safe parking site. Council rightly balked at the idea of undedicating parkland to pave it over and plant oversized vehicles.
I believe the best location is necessarily already paved over, underutilized, and in a location where conflicts between RV dwellers and other residents are reduced. However these forces already influenced where RV dwellers chose to live.
So: what should we do?
In the short-term we can manage it better. Enforce health and safety violations. Permit and register RVs to eliminate bad actors over time. Cap numbers at a manageable level that would surely please no one but be tolerable for most.
Long-term, we need a housing production strategy that is successful and local. Our best near-term option is to immediately and fully phase in SB 79 around our downtowns, along El Camino, and San Antonio. Ultimately, the cure for homelessness is more housing. That’s no fast answer, but given will and time, we can make our curbside workforce housing program obsolete.
Scott O’Neil is a Palo Alto resident and board member of Palo Alto Forward. He is writing this in his individual capacity.